Pasture raised beef vs Grass fed beef: What is the real difference? 

Pasture Raised Beef vs Grass Fed Beef

The main difference between pasture raised beef vs grass fed has to do with where the animal eats instead of what it eats. Both types of beef has their pros and cons, so let’s go over which type of beef will be best for you. 

What is Pasture Raised Beef?

Pasture raised beef is beef that comes from cattle raised on pasture. They graze grass and other forages as opposed to being confined in feedlots. This system typically involves regenerative agriculture practices such as, rotational grazing, where the cattle can mimic their natural behavior as much as possible. Pasture raised beef can be either grass finished or grain finished. This all depends on how the farmer or rancher chooses to feed their cattle. 

In pasture raised systems:

• Natural Diet: The cattle consume mostly grasses and other forages available in the pasture. This diet is more natural for cattle, as they are ruminants designed to digest grasses and other plant materials.
• Healthier Environment: Pasture-raised systems typically result in less stress for the animals, as they have more space to move around and engage in natural behaviors. This can lead to overall healthier animals.
• Environmental Benefits: Grazing animals on pasture can have positive environmental impacts, such as improved soil health, carbon sequestration, and biodiversity enhancement.
• Quality of Meat: Some advocates of pasture-raised beef argue that it produces meat with better flavor, texture, and nutritional profile compared to beef from cattle raised in feedlots. This is all personal preference though. 
• Nutrient Profile: This meat has superior nutrient profile when compared to conventional beef. It contains higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids, conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), vitamin E, and vitamin B.

It’s important to note that while pasture-raised beef is often associated with more sustainable and humane practices, not all pasture-raised systems are the same, and there can be variations in management practices and standards. To know exactly how your beef is raised, you need to speak to the farmer or rancher. 

Cons of Pasture Raised Beef

• Cost: Pasture-raised beef is typically requires more land and labor than conventional beef.
• Availability: Pasture-raised beef isn’t always available in the grocery store, so some forethought needs to happen on the consumers end. Usually this means buying a half beef or full beef from a local farmer or rancher. 

What is Grass Fed Beef?

Grass fed beef is beef that comes from cattle that have been primarily fed a diet of grass or forage throughout their lives. At some point, these cattle are usually brought to a feedlot to have a finishing period where they eat a diet of grains and hay. However, most all cattle in the beef industry start out their life drinking their mother’s milk and eating grass or hay. Some even spend at least part of their lives (typically during the grass growing season) on pasture. 

What is Grass Finished Beef?

Grass finished beef is beef that comes from cattle that have been fed a diet of only grass and forage throughout their entire life. 

In grass finished beef systems:

• Diet: Grass-fed cattle receive the majority of their nutrition from grazing on pasture. Their diet typically consists of grasses, legumes, and other forage found in natural pastures. Some producers may supplement with hay or silage during periods of limited forage availability, but grain is not a significant part of their diet.
• Natural Behavior: Grass-finished beef production typically allows cattle to exhibit their natural behaviors, such as grazing and roaming in open pastures.
• Healthier Fats: Grass-finished beef is often touted for its healthier fat profile compared to beef from grain-fed cattle. It tends to be leaner and contains higher levels of beneficial omega-3 essential fatty acids and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA).
• Environmental Benefits: Grass-fed beef production is generally considered more environmentally sustainable compared to conventional feedlot operations. Grazing cattle on pasture can improve soil health, promote biodiversity, and contribute to carbon sequestration.

Cons of Grass Finished Beef

• Flavor:​ Because all pastures have different grasses and forages in them, one beef may taste different than another. Unlike conventional feedlots that feed all cattle the same (for the most part), providing a similar outcome, grass-fed cows can end up tasting different. Along with this, some people really prefer the taste of grain-fed cows over grass. 
• Cooking: Grass finished beef has less fat than conventional beef. Therefore, learning a new way to cook your beef may be in order. 

What About Organic Beef?

You may see beef labels that say “beef from organic cattle” or “organic beef.” Organic beef is simply cattle raised according to the USDA’s definition of organic standards. The cattle’s diet includes organic feed that is free from certain pesticides, herbicides, and GMO’s. The USDA standards restrict the use of growth hormones and use of antibiotics. However, organic beef does NOT guarantee grass-finished or pasture-raised. These cattle can still be fed a diet of corn as long as it is not gmo corn. These cattle can be fed grain or grain byproducts, as long as they pass the federal regulations. 

Remember: Just because beef does not have organic labels, that doesn’t mean they aren’t truly organic. 

So, What Beef Should You Choose?

This all comes down to personal preference. Choose beef based off your health and dietary goals, your taste preference, and values. Don’t be afraid to reach out to local producers and ask questions about their beef products. That is truly the best way to find out about the quality of the meat. Then there is no need to worry about different labels that the food system keeps slapping on meat products. 

The good news is whether you choose the health benefits of pasture-raised cattle or prefer the taste of grain-finished beef, when you support local producers who prioritize ethical and sustainable practices,  you are fostering a healthier food ecosystem for everyone. 

Save Pasture Raised Beef vs Grass Fed for Later